Local Television Wins: BMI Must Offer AFBL

As I predicted here, Judge Stanton of the Southern District of New York has denied BMI’s motion that its consent decree does not require it to offer television broadcasters a blanket license the fee for which adjusts to reflect the degree to which a television broadcaster publicly performs musical works that it licenses directly from BMI-affiliated music publishers.  As is typical of his opinions, Judge Stanton quickly cut to the crux of the issue–is an adjustable fee blanket license a different kind of license or a traditional blanket license with a different fee structure?  Following the Second Circuit’s opinion in U.S. v. Broadcast Music, Inc. (In re AEI Music Network, Inc., 275 F.3d 168 (2d Cir. 2001), Judge Stanton concluded that an AFBL for broadcasters is still just a blanket license with a carve-out fee structure.

Judge Stanton’s opinion is below
[scribd id=54219728 key=key-1j2ymha1za0ijgijjsmn mode=list]